In a heartfelt tribute, his son David Caprio urged fans to "spread a little kindness" in honor of his father's legacy. Judge Caprio had captured the hearts of audiences by encouraging compassion in his courtroom, where he often engaged with defendants and showcased an understanding of their stories. His show amassed billions of views on social media, and Judge Caprio's unique style resonated with viewers, making his courtroom an inviting space.

Before his TV career, he presided over many cases in Providence, Rhode Island, and during his time, "Caught in Providence" received several Daytime Emmy nominations. He remained active in his fight against pancreatic cancer, sharing updates with followers and reflecting on his life’s journey. Judge Caprio leaves behind his wife Joyce, five children, seven grandchildren, and two great-grandchildren, with a legacy of kindness and compassion that inspired many.