Former leaders at the Countess of Chester Hospital in the UK are calling for a pause in the public inquiry into Lucy Letby’s reign of terror as a neonatal nurse, citing new evidence that might undermine her previously determined guilt. During a recent inquiry session, lawyer Kate Blackwell argued that the unexpected deaths of infants in 2015 and 2016 could stem from factors other than intentional harm, such as inadequate medical care and natural causes.

This inquiry follows Lucy Letby’s conviction for murdering seven infants, where she has continually asserted her innocence. The inquiry was initiated to investigate how such a tragedy could occur undetected for an extended period. However, significant questions have arisen about the validity of her convictions, highlighted by an extensive New Yorker article and testimony from various medical experts.

An independent panel of neonatal specialists has voiced concerns, stating they found no evidence implicating Letby, instead attributing the deaths to natural causes or poor medical treatment. The inquiry is grappling with the challenge of reassessing its findings in light of these new developments, raising essential discussions about justice and accountability in healthcare.