In a landmark decision, five former members of Canada's world junior hockey team were acquitted of sexual assault charges by an Ontario judge on Thursday. Justice Maria Carroccia evaluated the evidence and testimonials over the course of an intense eight-week trial. The players—Michael McLeod, Dillon Dube, Cal Foote, Alex Formenton, and Carter Hart—were accused of assaulting a woman, identified as EM, in a hotel room during a Hockey Canada gala in 2018.
After weighing EM’s testimony, Justice Carroccia found it lacked credibility and reliability, stating that “the Crown cannot meet its onus on any of the counts before me.” The heart of the case revolved around whether EM had given consent for the activities that took place. The defense argued that EM had invited the players into a sexual encounter and had communicated her consent.
During the trial, the courtroom was filled with spectators, highlighting the case's importance in Canada, particularly within the sports community. Justice Carroccia cited inconsistencies in EM's statements, which contradicted both her police report and subsequent testimonies. Notably, two videos presented during the trial depicted EM giving consent, though one was recorded without her knowledge.
While it remains uncertain whether the Crown will appeal the ruling, prosecutor Meaghan Cunningham acknowledged the public's support for EM and reiterated the importance of a fair trial for all parties involved. Throughout the trial, the Crown maintained that intoxication should not overshadow the validity of her assertions, while the defense pointed to evidence indicating EM's willingness to engage that night, despite her subsequent regrets.
The outcome has reignited discussions about consent and accountability in sports, as Canada grapples with the implications of sexual violence and the need for reforms within athletic organizations.
