Alcatraz, the infamous prison island once home to criminal legends like Al Capone, is making headlines again thanks to President Trump’s bold proposal to reopen it for incarceration. Trump believes Alcatraz can symbolize law and order, and recently stated he’s tasked his administration with exploring this idea. However, many prison experts pour cold water on the plan, calling it "not realistic" due to the prison's deteriorating state.

Originally a military fort, Alcatraz became a federal penitentiary in 1934 but shut its doors in 1963 due to high operational costs. Reports indicate it cost nearly three times as much to run compared to other federal prisons, and today, its ruins are managed as a historic site—attracting over 1.4 million visitors annually.

While Trump’s vision captures public interest, critics highlight that refurbishing Alcatraz poses logistical nightmares. Issues like crumbling infrastructure, lack of security, and outdated facilities would make it incredibly challenging to repurpose for modern usage. Experts agree that even a small-scale reopening seems implausible given the current condition of the prison.

Trump's idea is just one among many considered over the decades. The notion was previously looked into as a possible site for housing Cuban refugees during the 1980s but was ultimately deserted due to its historical significance and inadequate facilities. As excitement brews, the reality of Biden’s presidency might just keep Alcatraz firmly closed.