An unusual battle is unfolding over the Winter Olympics in Milan—not on the slopes or in the rinks, but on the internet. At its heart are Eileen Gu, a freestyle skier, and Alysa Liu, a figure-skater. Both are young women of American-Chinese heritage who were born and raised in the US and are champions in their field. Yet one is hailed as a trailblazer, while the other is seen as a traitor. Liu, daughter of a political activist, competes for the US, while Gu, representing China, is accused by some in the US of abandoning her roots for commercial gain. This divide reflects larger geopolitical tensions and the complexities surrounding national identity in today’s globalized world.