A Utah judge on Monday ordered the release of transcripts from a closed-door hearing about whether Tyler Robinson, charged with allegedly murdering conservative activist Charlie Kirk, must be shackled during court. The hearing took place in October, and the judge ordered the details to be public by day's end, supporting the media's push for transparency. Robinson has been charged with aggravated murder following the shooting of Kirk on September 10 at Utah Valley University. Prosecutors are seeking the death penalty.
Defense attorneys argued Robinson should appear in civilian clothing without restraints to prevent juror bias, yet the judge ruled that Robinson could wear civilian clothes but must wear restraints for safety. Judge Graf believes that these measures are necessary to protect court staff and the defendant in the event of disruptions.
Graf emphasized the foundational role of public transparency in the judicial system when ordering the release of the closed hearing details with limited redactions to protect specific security discussions. An audio recording of the hearing will also be released. Prosecutors will lay out their case against Robinson in a preliminary hearing set for May 18.
Defense attorneys argued Robinson should appear in civilian clothing without restraints to prevent juror bias, yet the judge ruled that Robinson could wear civilian clothes but must wear restraints for safety. Judge Graf believes that these measures are necessary to protect court staff and the defendant in the event of disruptions.
Graf emphasized the foundational role of public transparency in the judicial system when ordering the release of the closed hearing details with limited redactions to protect specific security discussions. An audio recording of the hearing will also be released. Prosecutors will lay out their case against Robinson in a preliminary hearing set for May 18.
